Viewing 3 replies - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • Thread Starter gdibble

    (@gdibble)

    Hypothetical situation/example:

    Consider a photo contest where A, B, C & D are choices.
    My first visit, I am presented with A vs C, and I click A.
    The page refreshes and shows me B vs D, so I click D.
    The page refreshes and shows me A vs D.
    Wait, I had clicked on both in previous votes.

    So here’s a thought:
    When the user votes, does the this-or-that plugin know if they have voted on that contest before?
    If it does, can we indicate to the user “You previously voted <thumbnail>. Cast new vote?”
    (Something to indicate their previous choice or at least that they voted on this contest before.)

    Plugin Author André Boekhorst

    (@andrex84)

    Hi gdibble,

    the plugin doesn’t just ‘add’ votes, but uses a chess algorithm. It’s a bit tough to explain, but this way it doesn’t matter how many times there will be voted on a single item.

    So, following your example; lets start with the 4 items with a rating of 1000.
    A: 1000,
    B: 1000,
    C: 1000,
    D: 1000,

    A vs C, click A: updated scored (approximately):
    A: 1020,
    B: 1000,
    C 980,
    D: 1000,

    B vs D, click D:
    A: 1020,
    B: 980,
    C: 980,
    D: 1020,

    A vs D, click D:
    A: 1000,
    B: 980,
    C: 980,
    D: 1020,

    Now, the ‘algorythm’ takes into account the likelyhood that one ‘item’ would win: So when you put B (980) to D (1020) you would believe D to become the winner. Because there is a larger differences between the player, they play for a larger ‘stake’ (for illustration purposes i made this 25pts):

    B vs D, click B
    A: 1000,
    B: 1005,
    C: 980,
    D: 995,

    I hope this gives a bit of insight on how the plugin works, but I realize this doesn’t resolve the issue that people aren’t limited to vote on a certain ‘item’.

    I guess I can use cookies to resolve this, but people would be able to delete then and cast a vote again. Otherwise we must think of user registration and such….

    For now, I’ll think of a clever way to make this happen through cookies.

    regards,
    André

    Thread Starter gdibble

    (@gdibble)

    Thanks for your reply, and the explanation. Totally makes sense to me, especially since I’m a Chess lover, but other less technical people I’m not so sure.

    Looking forward to your cookie idea/implementations.
    Appreciate all your work on this plugin – I think it’s one of the best available for voting.

Viewing 3 replies - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • The topic ‘multipe votes per contest?’ is closed to new replies.