Hannah,
It looks as though the top category items are just not being directed to the correct place.
The menu is directing the links to pages, but they should be going to categories.
Example:
Magical Medicines should be going to: http://hannahtangerine.com/?cat=5
NOT http://hannahtangerine.com/?page_id=5
You can fix this from within Appearances->Menus
Ah! I see what you mean. It’s weird it changed without me messing around with it at all.
I went to appearences>menus. But I don’t see where would I make the change?
The hyperlinks you provided are correct, and that’s how the link appeared before. Thanks for your help!
There should be a categories box under “Pages” on the Appearances -> Menus screen.
http://codex.wordpress.org/Appearance_Menus_Screen