I saw your last post but it's not shown here for some reason. (??)
I did take a deeper dive into your site and your theme is interesting. I can't tell if these are"Joomla" guys who started with a Joomla template and don't understand the conventions of writing a WordPress theme, or if they are trying to obfuscate the theme to make it harder for others to adapt. The
single-player.php template is not working properly largely because they have chosen to ignore some WP basics. In addition there were some directories like includes that I could not see from the WP admin page's editor. Moreover, a number of the standard templates that I would expect to see -
single.php, page.php, category.php, archive.php, comments.php - are missing. So I'm not quite sure how the theme is handling the WP template hierarchy.
I believe I can patch the single-player.php template so it will work in your them but:
(a) I don't want to mess with your existing templates, so you will have to set me up with a FTP account so I can do some patching and testing of
(b) you'll be on your own to update this template with any new release of Team Rosters.
If you don't want to go that route, I suggest you go to a more "WP standards compliant" theme or don't use the