Template Page looks different on "home" and "static" page

Hi, I hope someone will respond to my question (unlike the last time I posted). I have two pages, “home” (static) and “News and Announcements” (posts page)that are both using a home.php template I created. The news and announcements page looks nearly perfect, but the home page is not right. see: http://velocityvolleyballclub.org/news-and-announcements/ and http://velocityvolleyballclub.org/ I do not understand how this is possible, if they’re both running from the same page template? Is there something I need to change in functions.php or style.css to have them display correctly? I can provide more detail, but wanted to be brief. THANKS for any help!