This looked like Theme my Login was going to be a great plugin - I've been using CYC where I needed to hide the WP admin look, but it is limited. But at least it works!
I've installed TmL v5 onto a 2.9.2 install with very few other plugins running. One thing that I do need is a plugin to change emails to smtp not php_mail. But none of the user registration emails are sent (users need admin approval) although the admin notification of a pending user works fine. Also the profile page isn't themed although I did tick the box to say that it should be.
Is it just me? Do the older versions have the same features but less bugs?