Showing more than 1 page of results

On our site t: http://threepennymarket.com/etsy-store/
I have three pages of “plushies” on Etsy, but only the 1st page gets listed through the plugin. Is there a way to get all pages listed, or include the page buttons at the bottom of the section like it does on Etsy (see: https://www.etsy.com/shop/3PennyMarket?section_id=15380543&ref=shopsection_leftnav_3 )

https://wordpress.org/plugins/etsy-shop/