Showing 404 in cases where it should not

I had a post with slug: this-post.html
I had changed the slug to: post.html

Now wordpress open the post.html regardless of which one of the two url I hit. (Happens because it saves the old slugs too)

However, the plugin with report 404 for the this-post.html even though there is none 404.

https://wordpress.org/plugins/404-error-monitor/