Saved changes disappearing

I really like the ease of using your plugin. I’m running into a problem, though. I currently have two different fonts through WP Google Fonts. So, the Font 1 and Font 2 slots are filled. I want to add a third font. I’ll select a font for the Font 3 slot, enter the styles and elements for the font, and select save. The new font then appears in the Font 3 slot, as I would expect. But the changes are not appearing on my website. And, when I navigate away from the WP Google Fonts settings page, and then navigate back to it, the settings in the Font 3 slot have disappeared. It’s almost like they were never saved in the first place. I have tried using the other slots, but the same thing happens. Is there any reason why I would be limited to using two fonts on my site?

Thanks for your help. The website I’m working on is brandsparkmedia.com and I’m trying to alter the H5 element.

http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/wp-google-fonts/