Re-Captcha on Second Form not working

I have a contact form where re-captcha is working.

However I created a second form with a new code but the page is completely blank until I remove the re-captcha code tag in the second form. The current form code is below, but I currently have the recaptcha tag removed in production

<p>Your Full Name (required)
[text* your-name] </p>

<p>Your Email (required)
[email* your-email] </p>

<p>Mailing Address (required)
[textarea* mailing-address x1]</p>

<p>Your Phone Number (required)
[tel* tel-number] </p>

<p>Best Time to Call You (required)
[select* menu-timetocall “Morning” “Noon” “Evening”]</p>

<p>Your Local Time Zone (required)
[select* menu-timezone “Eastern” “Central” “Pacific”]</p>

<p>Are you Vegan? (required)
[checkbox* checkbox-vegan “Yes” “No”]</p>

<p>Do You Have A Milk Allergy? (required)
[checkbox* checkbox-milk “Yes” “No”] </p>

<p>Additional Information (optional)
[textarea info] </p>

<p>[recaptcha recaptcha-845]</p>

<p>[submit “Request My Free Shakeology Sample”]</p>

http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/contact-form-7/