WordPress.org

Ready to get started?Download WordPress

Forums

Possible comment spam solution for WP? (7 posts)

  1. Muffinboy
    Member
    Posted 9 years ago #

    On his blog Arve Bersvendsen talks about a comment spam solution he wants to implement in his own blogware. I think the approach shows promise and maybe it's something that WP could benefit from.
    In short:
    1) comments by unapproved commenters will be presented on the weblog stripped of all URLs, even plain text (not linked) URLs in the message body.
    2) links/URLs will be restored in the comment when a commenter is approved (as being a proper, responsible, human commenter)
    3) approval of a commenter, in Arve's proposal, can be done by a moderator or by gaining a minimum number of votes from already approved commenters.
    I'm not a coder, but I can see this work with WP. There already is a permission based user registration, so what is needed is making use of that system to define the different commenter roles and some code to strip any form of a link from a comment upon presentation.

  2. charle97
    Member
    Posted 9 years ago #

    the majority of blogs don't get the traffic and regular commenters to warrant this solution.

  3. Muffinboy
    Member
    Posted 9 years ago #

    That was my first reaction too, as you can see by the comments I left on Arve's post. However, Adam Kalsey's comment convinced me that this will also work in a situation with less traffic. The main point is not to focus on the 'moderation system' but on the stripping of the links.
    On a personal blog with not all that much traffic the 'regulars' can be approved quite quickly by the site owner (who is also moderator of course), while the incidental visitor can still leave comments, without having to end up in the moderation queue, because the only thing that happens to their comment is that links are stripped from their post. Links in a bona fide comment by an incidental commenter can be activated by the site owner/moderator at a later point. Commenters can of course be informed of the policy when/before posting.
    I think this system has the best of both worlds. If the commenter thinks it's worth the while to register with your blog then that's an extra check against spam, but when the commenter doesn't register, he or she can still leave his/her opinion, albeit initially without links.
    Comments by unregistered commenters should also go into the 'moderation' queue so that the site owner can decide whether or not to allow links on an unregistered comment-by-unregistered comment basis. This presents hardly any extra work for the site owner because you're probably already checking the moderation queue upon login, but it takes away the incentive for spammers, since their links will never get displayed, not even the short period between posting them and deleting them.

  4. charle97
    Member
    Posted 9 years ago #

    you might as well use typekey.

  5. Matt Mullenweg
    Troublemaker
    Posted 9 years ago #

    It's not just the links I don't want on my site, I don't want the filthy words either. 1.3 will offer emergent registration which is similar to what you describe, but not as intrusive.

  6. ihad
    Member
    Posted 9 years ago #

    ooo sounds groovy.
    bring it on! :D

  7. Muffinboy
    Member
    Posted 9 years ago #

    Sounds intriguing... looking forward to it :)

Topic Closed

This topic has been closed to new replies.

About this Topic

Tags

No tags yet.