Popularity Contest Plugin – I need a more in-depth template tag

Hello,
The Popularity Contest’s generic template tag will not do it for me. I need something more advanced. I am not using lists to display the most popular posts. I have thumbnails, comments, etc. that needs to be displayed as well.
Here’s the website that is having difficulties with Popularity Contest:
http://www.plutoswallet.com/

The problem is at the top of the page under Popular Deals. I need to display all those using Popularity Contest, but it only allows for a list.