what is the exact code of your inclusion of wp_paginate()?
if you look at this section from the html code in the browser:
<div id="nav-below" class="navigation">
<div class="navigation"><ol class="wp-paginate"><li><span class="title"></span></li><li><span class="page current">1</span></li><li><a href="http://www.honeycombsites.ca/alpha/key/category/electronic-key-box/page/2/" title="2" class="page">2</a></li><li><a href="http://www.honeycombsites.ca/alpha/key/category/electronic-key-box/page/2/" class="next">ยป</a></li></ol></div></div>
</div><!-- #nav-below -->
you can see an extraneous </div> there.
you need to find out if this is from your coding or from the plugin.
You are correct, there was an extra div tag after my
<?php if(function_exists('wp_paginate')) {wp_paginate();} ?>
Thank you, and sorry for overlooking this.