I really like the idea for this plugin, but I'm having a bit of an issue. I installed correctly, and changed the permalink to match my wordpress permalink. First, I used the default one, then I changed it to /%postname%/. However, I'm getting the same issue with either option.
When I leave a comment (not with an admin email), I see that my comment is shown, but it says that needs to be moderated (ok with that). Then I see that link at the bottom has changed to, " Your subscription to this entry needs to be confirmed. Manage your subscriptions." When I click on "manage your subscriptions," I'm taken to a 404 page or a Bad Request page.
Additionally, I've tried this a few times and sometimes I get an email at the email I subscribed with. When I click on the link to opt in, it goes to the same dead page.
The only way I can turn the email's status from "C" to "Y" is by manually updating it in the wordpress admin area.
Lastly, if I'm totally mucking something up, my bad - I'm not super tech savy with plugins/code, so if you use real simple terms, I won't be offended. Thanks for your help!