On a fresh install this plugin worked perfectly. For my current theme, Responsive(ThemeID) with a basic child theme, there is a P tag that is somehow getting added.
Email and Like show up without an issue, there was no direct plugin changes made, I'm using show before Content setting. But Pinterest and Google+ do not show up. Only difference between Test and Live(for this plugin) is that somehow(2) unclosed P tags are appearing.(Credit completely given to CoffeePerk on IRC, I spent time running in circles trying to find this.)