WordPress.org

Ready to get started?Download WordPress

Forums

[Plugin: Pods CMS] Best plugin for wordpress ever. period (22 posts)

  1. Benjamin Favre
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    Just thought I'd put it out there.

    If you need to add any kind of cms functionality to wordpress this is for you.

    You can literally do anything with your data. Just loving it.

    No need to hack things up any more, check it out at http://pods.uproot.us/

    http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/pods/

  2. designgears
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    I like magic-fields better.

  3. Benjamin Favre
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    Magic-fields / Flutter (share the same original source code by the way ), magic-fields beeing a fork off flutter and all... just piggy-back on to wordpress posts system by including pretty and user friendly "custom fields". Nothing you couldn't do manually by the way, just prettry stuff.

    I don't think you can compare a cms plugin as in "content" managing system like pods with a enhance my "posts" custom fields plugin.

    With flutter / magic-fields, all post still live in the same database table, they just have different custom fields enabled. By the way the custom fields/flutter "Content types" management/seperation system is totally wack by default.

    I do see instances where flutter/magic-fields can be usefull.
    I actually use the plugin my self to help my clients upload files and thumbnails to include in there posts: "ON THE BLOG"

    I do also see instances where you could use both.

    But if you want to actually to keep your blog posts seperate from say a business directory or anything that my take of some day.

    You have to stop and ask yourself :
    - where is my content beeing stored ?
    - what can i do with it ?
    - can I display the data any way I want for my users ?

    I just think that if your serious about your data, and find yourself wondering:
    "How am I going to build a work around to do want to do with post's and the wordpress category structure ?"
    "What about duplicate content ?"
    "Am I going to have to publish this article in different categories"
    and so on ..
    Then you should just stop there. Post's aren't for you. You're so used to worpress and the idea that you can do almost anything with posts and pages. ( The key word here is "almost")

    Maybe one day some one will want to buy your site, and they say ok, we're interested in your data, we like the site but we're going to make a new one.
    You're going to have to say, I'm sorry my data is just mixed up with all my blog posts.
    All there thinking now is, "Oh it's just a blog" ( I know some blogs are worth a lot by the way )
    Ok they will maybe/probably be able to do something about it.
    But you've just lost one major bargaining chip, and you just look like an amateur.
    If you were using pod's you could have said:
    "I'm running the site with wordpress. I use it for my news and blog posts because it's very convenient for our writers."
    "We have kept our data completely separate in the data base."
    "We can sell you the data, the blog, or both."

    At the end of the day flutter / magic-fields / more-fields is for the casual blogger who justs wants to blog on different topics and have some extra stuff displayed for each. Witch is totally cool and I love the work that is being done in that direction.

    But if you're getting serious and you don't want to be hacking thing's up with category id's, category templates, post templates, include here, exclude there and so on.

    And you just want something clean and professional, then Pod's is your best bet. Keep an eye out this is just the beginning of a wordpress revolution.

  4. Benjamin Favre
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    that's one long comment :P

  5. Monika
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    Pods needs a package insert:

    <b>Don't use Pods-you geht hooked on it!</b>

    ;-)

  6. harmonic400
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    Pods needs a second package insert:

    <b>Pods comes with no useful documentation.</b>

  7. Oliver Nielsen
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    Was unusable for me, php and mysql errors everywhere. Even when uninstalling. And yes, I tried. Even setting up stuff on my server with terminal, to suit the plugin. I guess it ain't that easy to program a whole CMS layer onto WordPress. ExpressionEngine and Drupal for me, when I need custom content types. Pods is too unstable. And what happens in the future? Imagine you build a site for a client, and he updates his WordPress, only to find Pods got messed up. Then the site will be ******, since all the custom content type "Pods" will break. Damn. No thanks.

    Some might say this is due to my server, but being on Media Temple, my server is pretty obedient and compatible.

    And to get back to my client example: What happens if you one day move this clients site to another server / host? Then it may or may not work.

    Waste of my time, this plugin.

  8. logikal16
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    Did you bother asking for help in the Pods forum?

  9. luminopolis
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    Agreed 100% with olivernielsen - this plugin has tons of issues to work out before it can be considered usable. Nevermind whether or not someone bothered to ask for help in the forms - there's a lot wrong with Pods including a very basic syntax error in pods/uninstall.php that makes it impossible to uninstall the standard wordpress way. Tons of database problems too - some potentially injectable and some just dirty.

    Neat idea, looking forward to its evolution. Not a good option just yet.

  10. luminopolis
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    also - magic fields is superior for most applications involving post field customization, even if it's mostly aesthetic in its approach. it does what one would expect pods to do, in a much simpler fashion.

  11. logikal16
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    Typical mindset from the WordPress community. Instead of complaining about how buggy a plugin is, why not contribute and help make it better?

    It's kind of what open source is all about.

    We didn't set up forums and an IRC channel for nothing. If you want to see Pods evolve into something more user-friendly and stable, then maybe it's time to consider giving a little bit back to the community.

    Otherwise, happy mooching.

  12. shauno
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    Typical mindset from the WordPress community. Instead of complaining about how buggy a plugin is, why not contribute and help make it better?

    It's kind of what open source is all about.

    *Round of applause*

    As a developer I wholeheartedly endorse this general sentiment!

  13. IEBA
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    I just happened to peruse this thread but this last exchange prompted me to comment...

    I use a car, but I'm not a mechanic.
    I use a computer, but I'm not a troubleshooter.
    I use a TV, but I'm not an engineer.

    Because I use WordPress does not mean I can be, or want to be, a software engineer. There's not enough time in the world for me to become expert enough to fix every product I use.

    I appreciate those who code. I appreciate those who contribute. I really appreciate those who help non-coders like me. But Open Source is for those who choose to open it. Like the hoods on cars, there are those of us who, when needed, let those who specialize in such things do what they do, handily.

    If you came to me to produce a TV show for PBS, I would not look down at you because you couldn't produce it yourself and meet PBS' engineering, timing, and delivery specifications. That's not your job. It's mine. So don't look down at those who don't get involved in helping code open source software.

    Thanks.

  14. logikal16
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    IBEA - Every comment has some level of context.

    luminopolis mentioned:

    Tons of database problems too - some potentially injectable and some just dirty.

    This clearly implies some database knowledge. If he claims that some of the database queries are "dirty", then why not help us by showing (specifically) which queries he's talking about, and how to improve them?

    You don't have to be a programmer to contribute, even to Pods. All documentation has room for improvement. If you figure something out, then a blog post or tutorial will undoubtedly help someone else down the line. If you're a producer that wants a new UI, then come up with a quick mock-up.

    If your new car is broken, wouldn't you take it to the repair shop (e.g. Forums, IRC chat) before sending it to the junkyard? The developers are pretty easily accessible, and it makes no sense to me why some community members are so quick to criticize.

  15. wesbos
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    I was amazed at how active this plugin is being developed. I have been hanging out in the chat room for a while and there is always someone to help you out.

    Pods isn't perfect, but the developers are working their asses off trying to make it so. Flutter is abandoned, you guys should be happy that we have a plugin being so actively developed. If you have a problem, report it; im sure a fix will be either already available or come out within a week or two.

  16. Scott Kingsley Clark
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    I don't believe there's any plugin that is 'perfect' or 'complete', as every developer strives to continue the process of setting goals and reaching them to enhance plugins to fit the always growing needs of users.

    Pods just happens to have a very high learning curve because (personally) I believe that most WP users expect simple solutions with a point-and-click-and-you're-done interfaces. While although we're working on making Pods easier for non-developers - we're focusing our time on developing new features and ideas that make Pods more powerful for the needs of developers with moderate to complex projects on WP.

    Pods is constantly in development and isn't a pet project of a company - it's an open source community project that we encourage everyone to participate in. Pods has certainly grown greatly and has been gifted with some really useful features since Late Fall 2008 when it was first released.

    We highly encourage the community (and the WP community) to provide any critiques, reviews, tutorials, code, packages, and documentation that they feel will contribute towards making Pods even better.

    designgears - harmonic400 - olivernielsen - luminopolis - IEBA: You all have your valid points but if you ever want a walkthrough of what Pods does, and how it works, let me know. I'm available. I challenge each of you to be as descriptive as possible in responding to this thread with your thoughts and input on how we can make Pods better for you. You can contact me through IRC on irc.freenode.net on the #podscms channel (or at http://pods.uproot.us/chat/) - or via my contact form at http://www.scottkclark.com/contact/

    Any Pods 1.7.x versions above 1.7.6 will strictly be bug fix releases as we patch up all currently known bugs. I encourage you to provide any bugs you have experienced, even for versions beyond 1.7.x

  17. shauno
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    Hi IEBA

    No to get involved in something I really shouldn't, but you mention the following:

    If you came to me to produce a TV show for PBS, I would not look down at you because you couldn't produce it yourself and meet PBS' engineering, timing, and delivery specifications. That's not your job. It's mine. So don't look down at those who don't get involved in helping code open source software.

    You mention that producing the TV show is you job. Exactly, you get paid to do it, so you better do a damn fine job.

    Plugin developers are putting the work out there for nothing. They have day jobs.
    Don't get me wrong, we enjoy it, and really want feedback. We understand you are using the our plugins because you might not be a PHP developer, and in most cases happy to bend over backwards to help. But it strikes a nerve when people expect stuff for nothing.

    Anyway, logikal16, I haven't used PODs yet myself, but I have a friend who can't stop raving about it. Keep up the good work!

  18. jimisaacs
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    Just stepping into this thread... and I have to say...

    Go here http://pods.uproot.us/about/

    You see how much work has gone into this plugin, and how many people have actually worked on it since it's conception.

    It is quite amazing. I actually wonder if any of you guys have slept in a while or if your dreams are haunted with code, logic, and error messages.

    ---

    I wrote in another thread that after trying Pods I believe it is doing something so simple and yet so beautiful in which how it handles the database.

    How many CMS systems are out there using Open Source as their base and their mission? Drupal, Joomla, WordPress to name the big three. I believe they could all learn a big lesson with the simple logic behind Pods.

    Features are exactly what the word means, FEATURES. The base system is very simple and I am having a ball with it myself. Features will follow, and users shouldn't say it is unusable because a button isn't blue or the WYSIWYG isn't WordPressified. It is being worked out, just like WordPress itself! (Page Ordering, for the love of @#$)

    I have a personal WordPress framework I have built and have been using based entirely on Widgets, and I wanted to get it to a point so I can release. Now I also want to get involved with Pods, so I'm torn thank you very much. I guess I'm going to have to fart this thing I have out the door as soon as I can so I can get into Pods more heavily.

    Thank you guys again for actually thinking before building. Believe me it shows ;)

  19. Jay August
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    Oh My God I no longer need Drupal. Amazing :)

  20. automaton
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    I've been doing lots of tests with both Pods and Flutter over the past few weeks.
    In the beginning I thought both were a different approach to the same problem (custom content types) and I guess in some ways they are. But it's not that simple. It's perfectly OK to use Pods and Flutter alongside eachother, in fact they are quite complementary.
    In my view, use Pods if:

    1. You need custom content that is totally separate from your Blog posts and is structurally very different, ie. not 'post-like' at all. Like restaurant addresses or a product catalog.
    2. You know your PHP and MySQL and need a platform to integrate your own expertise and code into WordPress without inventing the wheel all over again.
    3. You want an efficient database structure because the amount of (custom) data is rather large
    4. You don't need/want to tag or categorize your custom content via the WordPress taxonomy system

    Use Flutter if:

    1. Your custom content is basically a 'post with benefits'. All Flutter does is add a more user-friendly interface to custom fields. Which is exactly what you need in many cases. Some examples would be a blog where you post different types of articles: a 'video' post, a book review, a how-to article, etc.
    2. Your PHP knowledge is limited, you just want something that works right away in a transparent fashion.
    3. You want your custom content posts to appear alongside your 'regular' posts in the loop, category overviews, etc.
    4. Your website is more like a 'flow of updates' (blog) than a 'data repository' (wiki/catalog)

    This is the result of my own personal research, other people undoubtedly have other opinions/experiences. I'd like to see what the creators of Flutter and/or Pods think of this comparison, though.

    Personally, I think there is a gap between these two plugins for another kind of 'in-between solution'. Allow me to explain:
    A plugin that, like Flutter, uses posts as its basis for content. This would mean that any piece of content needs at least a title, an author, a category and a body (description).WP experts, correct me if there are any other required fields.
    But, unlike Flutter, this plugin should store its metadata not in wp_post_meta but in separate tables based on the content type, like Pods.
    This would include custom content types in the loop automatically, but it would also make the database cleaner and easier to manage/export/scale.

  21. Downsouth
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    The documentation is a bit sparse and I'm definitely no PHP expert, but I kept at it. The forums are good and so far as I can see every issue gets an answer.

    The devs are excellent. Scott and Logikal helped me when I was stuck and even logged in to my site and solved my final issue. You can't get better support than that - absolutely wonderful !

    There are some things which did really frustrate me: date-handling and search being the main ones, but overall this is a fantastic addition to WordPress.

    To get started you really need to watch the excellent video tutorial. (I wish they'd make some more!)

    Here's the tutorial:
    http://vimeo.com/6957771

  22. tomhermans
    Member
    Posted 4 years ago #

    PODS is definitely THE best plugin for WP. Sure there's room for improvement, or better documentation, but this thing makes WP so much more versatile. No more hassling with custom fields etc, but seperate tables with all kinds of data you want. Built in editors and uploaders etc.., magic tags etc..

    And if you know PHP, this extends WP even further, endless possibilities.

Topic Closed

This topic has been closed to new replies.

About this Topic

Tags