[Plugin: Facebook Share (New) Button] Share on Home page only showing once?

The plugin is working really nicely on individual posts, thank you!

However on my Home page its only showing once, in my right menu, instead of with each post… any ideas?
See photo here: http://www.fertilefc.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/FB-Share-issues.png

I’m using the Platform Pagelines theme.

Thanks for any help.