I am using the custom community theme and on the Unlocked By list for an achievement it lists most but not all members, whether or not they have unlocked the achievement. It also shows everyone as having unlocked it Unlocked 42 years, 3 months ago ago. This is the same for all achievements.
I noticed that this list is provided by members-loop.php by your plugin does not contain this so I assume it must be using the one from my theme?
Any suggestions on how to fix this?