I am using a custom template to show my blog, so I am not using the index.php, archive, single or category. I have a query to show all my posts. In my settings I have set it to show 5 posts.
When I view the page I can see the links to go forward and back, but if I click the link, it always takes me to the same 5 posts.
The page I'm working on is:
http://www.sidewalkcafedesign.com/blog-3