I could've sworn I had this plugin working great for me with 2.8.4. Upgraded to 2.9 this morning on a client site and it now "half works." The top level pages are all still restricted. However, child pages are viewable without needing to be logged in.
Anyone else stumbled over a similar issue? I can fix it by messing with the site navigation to hide the option but am open to a plugin fix/hack as well.