I don't know when this became a problem, but for a while I have not been receiving an email when someone comments:
- I have the box checked: "Email me whenever" "Anyone posts a comment"
- I do get emails when a comment is held for moderation or someone signs up.
- I have tried unselecting the check box, saving changes; then reselecting the box and saving changes with no effect.
Any help tracking this issue down would be appreciated.