I've just taken over an established WordPress site and I've discovered a rather annoying problem. In the News section of the site, you are able to go back to Page 2, but not any further. Or, to be more accurate, the url shows that you can go back to Pages 3 and 4, but they display the same posts as Page 2.
Here's a link to the site: http://midnightechomagazine.com/news/
I'm using WordPress 3.4.1 and the theme is Easel 3.1. I am very new to WordPress (to the point of still figuring out how to navigate the Dashboard), so any advice on how to fix this problem (and where to do it) would be hugely appreciated.