Unfortunately, that is not an option. The powers that be will say to forget about subscribe2 :( And I know it's the best choice of a plugin for what we need.
I had actually copied the live server - the database and the wordpress directory - over to the test server environment before I upgraded the test server from 3.4.2 to 3.5 and installed subscribe2. Then I did the upgrade and install on the live server. So any problems in the live server *should* have propagated to the test serer.
Any other suggestions? I just tried copying the subscribe2_options option_value from the test server to the live server for wp_15_options, but I'm still seeing the same behavior.
a:40:{s:7:"autosub";s:2:"no";s:15:"newreg_override";s:2:"no";s:8:"wpregdef";s:2:"no";s:10:"autoformat";s:7:"excerpt";s:12:"show_autosub";s:3:"yes";s:11:"autosub_def";s:3:"yes";s:12:"comment_subs";s:2:"no";s:11:"comment_def";s:2:"no";s:17:"one_click_profile";s:2:"no";s:8:"bcclimit";i:1;s:11:"admin_email";s:4:"none";s:8:"tracking";s:0:"";s:6:"s2page";i:2;s:10:"stylesheet";s:3:"yes";s:5:"pages";s:2:"no";s:8:"password";s:2:"no";s:8:"stickies";s:2:"no";s:7:"private";s:2:"no";s:10:"email_freq";s:5:"never";s:10:"cron_order";s:4:"desc";s:10:"compulsory";s:0:"";s:7:"exclude";s:0:"";s:6:"sender";s:8:"blogname";s:12:"reg_override";s:1:"1";s:9:"show_meta";s:1:"1";s:11:"show_button";s:1:"1";s:4:"ajax";s:1:"1";s:6:"widget";s:1:"1";s:13:"counterwidget";s:0:"";s:14:"s2meta_default";s:0:"";s:7:"entries";i:25;s:6:"barred";s:0:"";s:15:"exclude_formats";s:0:"";s:8:"mailtext";s:215:"{BLOGNAME} has posted a new item, '{TITLE}'
{POST}
You may view the latest post at
{PERMALINK}
You received this e-mail because you asked to be notified when new updates are posted.
Best regards,
{MYNAME}
{EMAIL}";s:20:"notification_subject";s:20:"[{BLOGNAME}] {TITLE}";s:13:"confirm_email";s:229:"{BLOGNAME} has received a request to {ACTION} for this email address. To complete your request please click on the link below:
{LINK}
If you did not request this, please feel free to disregard this notice!
Thank you,
{MYNAME}.";s:15:"confirm_subject";s:40:"[{BLOGNAME}] Please confirm your request";s:12:"remind_email";s:348:"This email address was subscribed for notifications at {BLOGNAME} ({BLOGLINK}) but the subscription remains incomplete.
If you wish to complete your subscription please click on the link below:
{LINK}
If you do not wish to complete your subscription please ignore this email and your address will be removed from our database.
Regards,
{MYNAME}";s:14:"remind_subject";s:34:"[{BLOGNAME}] Subscription Reminder";s:7:"version";s:3:"8.7";}