A link to your site/blog page would be most helpful, brian914!
But I think I understand what you are describing. The challenge is once the site visitor clicks to see the actual blog post, they are technically no longer “under the Tastings & Events” page, from WordPress’ perspective. The install is now using the single.php page (or some other custom page you might have set up), but they are “posts” not “pages”.
I know that doesn’t answer you question, per se, however, it might point you in a better direction.
Cheers!