Messages aren't getting emailed to me

I love this plugin but for some reason, when people send me a message using the contact form I don’t get a notification in my email. It does however save a copy in the “saved submission” section, but I really need a notification sent to me. Any suggestions of how I can get this to work? My contact form is located at http://thechicspy.com/?page_id=19449.

Thanks!

http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/custom-contact-forms/