I'm not sure how it was done. I have just taken over this site a couple months ago and it was already there. This website is a total mess. I do html and have never worked with WordPress until I took over this site. So I am trying to learn as I go.
On the member sign-in the selection is on the "Ignore the default settings and make this page visible only to members" And it goes to the login page. But on the Newsletter page which is to go to the login page too, the setting is on "Ignore the default settings and make this page visible to everyone" I have clicked to have it go to the members only but it won't stay there and says "everybody" on the list of pages.
I hope I have explained it so you know where I'm coming from. Is there a "save" button that I can't find?