@jcoleman I had a look at your site, and your theme seems to be loading an old version of jQuery (1.3.2) instead of using the version that comes bundled with WordPress (1.8.3 at the moment).
It can create multiple conflicts with WordPress and with other plugins like Jetpack. You can read more about it here:
The problems with the sharing buttons and the Pinterest button are caused by this old library.
You'll want to look for the function loading jQuery in your theme's header.php file, or in the functions.php file. Once you find that function, you can remove it and enqueue the proper version of jQuery as explained here:
If you do not feel comfortable editing PHP files, you can also contact the theme or plugin author and ask them to solve the issue.