Posted 4 months ago #
Many of our users are reporting that the Jetpack commenting isn't working, though I haven't been able to reproduce the error. Here's a sample post: http://www.fromaway.com/observations/from-away-mercantile-announcement-plus-giveaway
Users are reporting that they are signed into WordPress, but when they try and comment, they are asked to login again. Other users are saying that they have left comments, but that they aren't appearing. Can anyone help?
Posted 4 months ago #
I see you have now deactivated Jetpack on your site.
Do you have any other active Comment or Anti Spam plugins on your site? Some plugins are indeed known to cause conflicts with Jetpack Comments:
http://jetpack.me/troubleshooting/known-issues/
Posted 4 months ago #
This is a problem all over at the moment.
When I'm logged in to wordpress.com with my jetpack I used to be able to comment directly. But now there are many blogs, both at wordpress.com and stand alone wordpress.org blogs that don't recognized me.
This started after the last update for Jetpack.
And for the blogs I run there are no other active comment or antispam other than askimet.
Posted 4 months ago #
If you experience similar issues on WordPress.com sites and on different Jetpack sites, the problem might not be linked to Jetpack.
Could you please try clearing out your cache and cookies, and see if this helps?
http://en.support.wordpress.com/browser-issues/#clear-your-cache-and-cookies
Could you also let me know what happens when you try to leave a comment? Do you receive an error message?
Posted 4 months ago #
We are many different users that experience this problem. Different browsers, and a lot of different pages
Both at wordpress.com and wordpress.org blogs.
Clearing cache and cookies was my first try, and then different browsers, but that doesn't solved this.
Mostly the comment just disapper from the screen, no "your comment awaiting moderation" alert, it just disapper, but the blog-owner can retrive the comment from the spam-filter.
Maybe you can see the problem from my blog-page
http://www.havheksa.no/info
the page is in norwegian
But that can't do anything, this happens on danish and german sites too
Posted 4 months ago #
the blog-owner can retrive the comment from the spam-filter.
Thanks for that extra detail. If your comment appears in the Spam filter, it means it was successfully posted.
If all your comments are considered as Spam, by mistake I would recommend that you contact Akismet about it:
http://akismet.com/contact/
Posted 4 months ago #
Okey, I'll try to do that
Thank you so far, and if I find a solution I will post it here to ;)
Posted 4 months ago #
I actually just had someone inform me this morning that they posted a comment to a post of mine overnight and it didn't appear. According to them, they'd signed in with their WordPress account, typed a comment, hit post, and... nothing. It's definitely not posted, not in moderation, and not in spam.
Posted 4 months ago #
Oh, and now I can tell you why, sort of. Upon hitting post, the Jetpack comments iframe refreshes to... a page that's a 404 error.
Once again, it's because a plugin for some reason is not correctly calling *WordPress URL* and is calling *Site URL* instead.
Hence it goes to
http://furiousnads.com/wp-comments-post.php?for=jetpack
which doesn't work, because it should be wordpress/wp-comments-post.php?for=jetpack
ETA that if I disable Jetpack comments, native WordPress commenting functions fine. So, it's something about Jetpack comments being active.
Posted 4 months ago #
@theonetruebix I tried to leave a comment on your blog a few minutes ago, and it worked. I have also tested leaving comments on a test blog of mine, using a different WordPress URL and Site URL, and it seems to work properly.
Do you have any other comment plugins active on your site?
Posted 4 months ago #
Yeah, sorry, since I wasn't sure it was the same issue, I started a new thread
http://wordpress.org/support/topic/jetpack-comment-submission-leads-to-404-error
where we went through the issue.
You must log in to post.
