I have been using Evolve for few montha now, and I'm happy with it.
For an inexperienced user like me, its easy to customize, although it has limited options, all works well.
You can check out how it looks here:
and mail me your comments at ptc(at)o2.pl
I have some problems with evolve child theme, when i made one, the header crashes in child... My fault since I didnt do it at begining, and now its hard to change everything.
To sum up, theme works well, looks good, easy to set up for beginners, easy to maitain.
After a while lack of advanced customizing options is annoying - but there is an answer to that - time to learn more coding.. :)
(thats why 4 instead of 5 stars)