Forms sent sucessfully but NOT being received in email

When filling out the form at http://eppinecreekcabins.com/contact-us/ and hitting “send” the # Sender’s message was sent successfully message comes up. However, the email is not being received, and I have tried several email addresses from 3 independent servers. Here is my Form code:

[ Moderator note: fixed the code block. ]

<p>Your Name (required)
    [text* your-name] </p>

<p>Your Email (required)
    [email* your-email] </p>

<p>Requested Cabin (required)
[select* RequestedCabin include_blank "Pine Cabin" "Squirrels Nest" "Murphy’s Riverside Cottage" "Knotty or Nice Cabin" "Cliff View Cabin" "Bear Bottom Cabin" "Peaceful Pines Cabin" "Flower Lane Cabin" "Rock Bottom Retreat" "Little Brown Cabin" "Martin’s Mountain Hideaway" "Three Peaks Cabin" "Wile Away Cottage" "Aikin House" "Golf Course Condo" "O’Deer Cabin"]</p>

<p>Requested Dates (required)
[text* RequestedDates watermark "(MM/DD/YY)"]</p>

<p>Number of people in party (required)
[text* Party watermark "Example: 2 adults 2 children"]</p>

<p>Will you be bringing pets? (required)
(Only applicable for pet friendly cabins)
[text* Pets "Example: 2 dogs"]</p>

<p>Other Comments or Questions
    [textarea your-message] </p>

<p>[submit "Send"]</p>

And here is my message body:

From: [your-name] <[your-email]>

Requested Cabin: [RequestedCabin]

Requested Dates: [RequestedDates]

# in Party: [Party]

Pets? [Pets]

Message Body:
[your-message]

--
This mail is sent via contact form on Pine Creek Cabins http://www.eppinecreekcabins.com

Under mail, in the “To” section I have tried several addresses.

Please help, thanks!

http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/contact-form-7/