I found the problem at least for me! Forgot to post about it. It isn't the plugin that is the problem, its the host (where your site is hosted). I just needed to contact my hosting company and have them fix the problem. I do not have my email hosted with them, so there was an issue with wordpress sending the email. I don't know the exact fix, my husband talked through it all with the hosting company.
Best thing to do is to log into your cpanel and look at your "Default Email Account", which is basically a catchall email that is set up when you sign up for hosting. If you log into it you will see your emails there. Explain it to your host and they should be able to fix it.