Facebook count displays sum total of likes for site instead of individual posts

Hello! I recently added this plugin and love it. The problem is my two most recent posts’ facebook like count starts at 3000+! It should start at 0. I’ve checked in other browsers and they all display the wrong counts. Please help.

Examples of issue:
one

You can see the issue live at cookieandkate.com

Thank you,
Kate

http://wordpress.org/plugins/floating-social-bar/

https://wordpress.org/plugins/floating-social-bar/