Embed RSS tag feeds into Page Issues

I am having an issue with a plugin I recently installed, and I hope that someone here can provide a better solution to a problem I am having.

I have created several pages on my site that run RSS post tags to put all relevant posts under each player profile. This is being done with a plugin called Embed RSS

Unfortunately, the feed does not always load and I am left with a partial blank screen.

This is an example of a working page:

http://rookieblitz.com/players/db/morganburnett10/

This one works about once in 20 or more attempts:

http://rookieblitz.com/players/qb/jimmyclausen10/

I would prefer to not use a plugin, is there another way I could accomplish a similar result to what I have already built?

Thank you in advance,

Bryan