I just used the Duplicator plugin to duplicate my wordpress site. I then removed all the content from the duplicate site that I made, which is also running on a different unrelated URL and I started making a new site from it with new content that is different than the original.
The problem is all my subscribers and stats from my original site are still tied to this new site. When I post stuff on this new site people on my old site are receiving email notifications about the new posts now from a new site they did not actually subscribe to.
What can I do to fix this and to prevent this from happening when I duplicate another site in the future?
Subscribers are getting upset with me and I need to get this resolved quickly.