I thought it was an issue of cookies, but I've check that and don't think it is.
If I sign out of my wordpress account and go to aboutme.propprintables.com I am taken to aboutme.propprintables.com/#all wherein I see an old theme which I deleted from my files. It should show the site I've been building and which shows up if I'm signed in.
Any help would be oodles of awesome. Thanks!!