How do you know that the error wasn’t yours? How do you know that the support is poor when you didn’t try to contact the plugin’s author about this by posting a topic in the plugin’s dedicated sub-forum?
Try reviewing:
http://pippinsplugins.com/how-to-leave-a-good-bad-review/
http://chrislema.com/theres-wrong-way-give-plugin-feedback-wordpress-org/
Ok. Correction:
The plugin does not work FOR ME.
..and no, I don’t know if the error is mine, as I have had no reply to the question I posted in the plugins dedicated sub-forum three weeks ago.
Try reviewing:
http://wordpress.org/support/topic/new-comment-email-with-oldest-comment?replies=1