I add everything I'm supposed to. When I copy the link and paste directly to Facebook I get a random image and just text. I run it through debugger and get a lot of errors. Tested on both a page and blog article. The image it puts up isn't even hosted on my website. Really strange. I don't know what to do. You can log in if you need to. Currently the site is hidden because of updating. but you can go to http://www.redemptionpoint.net/preview to see the whole site.
Also, the theme's built in share button does the same thing.