bbPress search results not restricted

In the process of setting up a members only forum site using bbPress and PMPro. Have the PMPro bbpress plugin and everything seems to work as should except if you use the bbPress forums search it returns what I would consider full, unrestricted results.

You can see here http://www.contractorunited.com/find-your-board/ and use the search box to search ‘testing.’

In Advanced settings search is set to “Yes- only members will see . . .” and even “Hide excerpts” but it seems to return the same results no matter how I have it set.

Is this how it should be? Or is there a way to better restrict forum search results? Ideally, I would like a non-member to be able to search and see excerpts, which would in turn, of course, motivate signing up. As it is though, seems like they could get a lot of what they were looking for without signing up.

So, any way to change this? Could I have something simple off or to the wrong setting somewhere?

Any help appreciated.

PS – rest of the site setup at this point is fairly simple. Using Twenty Twelve with no customization, most plugins are just bbPress extensions, a few others like WP SEO

https://wordpress.org/plugins/paid-memberships-pro/