I reinstalled the original version(I've edited it quite a bit) of subscribe2 which I know was working at some point and the problem persisted, so any problem may not even lie in the plugin, but I noticed this problem and can't seem to figure it out:
When a user enters their email address and then hits enter or clicks the subscribe button, it takes them to this page(http://www.kgstiles.com/order-private-2-hour-comprehensive-astro-mapping-session/) My website is http://www.kgstiles.com. At first I thought this was totally random, but then I noticed that this page is the very first one in alphabetical order in my "Pages" list. Again, I don't even think this is a problem with the plugin, but has this ever been reported? Any suggestions on how to combat it?