Activated Users unable to log in

Hey, I have set up users that register on my site to sign up and then ability to log into the site once we activate them from the list view. However, when I activated my account, opened another browser and logged in with that new user account, I get this message:

ACCOUNT PENDING: Your account is currently not active. An administrator needs to activate your account before you can login.

I already activated the account? Why would it do that? Is there another setting somewhere I can change to avoid this?

Thanks!

http://wordpress.org/plugins/wp-members/