PageOfPosts.php

the code in your pastebin clearly states that the page template is for Twenty Ten;
you need to adapt it to Twenty Eleven by changing a few things;

try
pageofposts.php for twenty eleven:

http://pastebin.com/V96YZ4mT

do to the coding of twenty eleven, there is likely to be some issue with the sidebar (if you want one) on the page with this page template.

btw:
don’t edit twenty eleven directly; create a child theme http://codex.wordpress.org/Child_Themes and make the edits in there.
it is important to have an unedited default theme in case of general theme problems;
also, any customisations to twenty eleven will be overwritten with the next upgrade of your wp version.