I feel like Brett Favre… please help me decide!!!

My eyes are falling out I have looked at soooo many themes…

Can you guys help me out with a difficult decision? I don’t even know what looks good anymore I’ve looked at so many themes. This is for a church and I think we probably need something fairly modest in design but any suggestion at all is welcome. I think I will narrow it down to a top 5 of your suggestions and my picks and go from there… but really if any of you use wordpress for church or have any ideas at all It would be extremely helpful for me.

Requirements:
Widget Ready
Ability for podcast and video
Blogging
Picture at the top or slider at the top with ability for pictures
Clean and readable
Ability to post weekly bulletin which there possibly is a widget or plug-in for that

This is for a church and I don’t have a lot of requirements. This theme can be free or paid it doesn’t matter. I would like support though so paid is probably better. I really want it to look very good but that is relative I guess.