Why Am I Getting ALL Pages on Every Page?

I’ve been out of the web design area for a bit of time, but now have to do a site for myself. I’m using the Mantra theme.

I have set the front page to be static. Right now, I only have 4 pages because I don’t want to go on until I get this resolved.

I’m trying not to have to write any code as I’m programming other things and don’t know css.

I’ve created a menu… two items, both pages of the 4 I’ve created. Yet, on each page, I get ALL pages as if they’re posts… I think I’ve turned posts off, but not positive. I want to create a regular site here, not a blog, and I need separate pages to be separate pages.

Why are all 4 pages showing up on each of the two pages linked by the menu & tabs?

I need to add that I’ve tried all layout templates for each page. Category Page with Intro does the same thing as a single column page.

I’m using Firefox 29, but also have Chrome & IE. As I recall from when I did all of this stuff two years ago or so, IE was terrible when it came to working with WordPress sites.

Thanks in advance…