Escape characters in text

For the “Action after email is sent” text, I used a contraction: I’ll get back to you. But “I’ll” is showing up on the webpage as “I\’ll”. On the Settings page, “I’ll” automatically gets changed to “I\’ll” when I save the changes.

In my .htaccess file for the site, I already have magic quotes turned off, which usually fixes this problem. I wasn’t able to find anything about this in the documentation. And I don’t see where I can edit this directly in the source code.

It doesn’t show up in the message text submitted by the user, just in the thank-you message after they hit Submit.

How can I fix this on the web page? Thanks.

http://wordpress.org/plugins/contact-form-plugin/