Flexi Pages Plugin not working

I installed the Flexi Pages widget about 4 months ago and it was working fine on our site. Now, ALL of my Flexi Pages widgets show up on each page.

For instance, I have our “About Us” widget set to “Show on Selected” with the target URLs of about/* and about. So, that widget should only show up on the About Us section. However, it is showing up on all of my pages.

http://www.fbcsudbury.org.
http://www.fbcsudbury.org/visiting/sunday/
http://www.fbcsudbury.org/about/story/

Any help would be great!