Yup, I’d say something’s broken with your theme.
my theme’s single.php has a link like this:
<a href="#comments"><?php comments_number('No Comments', 'One Comments', '% Comments' );?></a>
which helps land those comments clicks. What’s your theme’s single.php like?
Your theme might have something like this in comments.php
<h3 id="comments"><?php comments_number('No Responses', 'One Response', '% Responses');?> to “<?php the_title(); ?>”</h3>
The above code displays a header element <h3 id="comments"> above the post which will read (say):
No responses to "Oranges Grow on Trees"
One response to "Oranges Grow on Trees"
5 responses to "Oranges Grow on Trees"
<h3 id="comments"> acts as an anchor.
Any link to a comment where the link has been created using <?php comments_popup_link();?> automatically has either #comment or #respond added on to the end of the link.
Links with no comments have #comment added.
Links WITH comments have #respond added.
See: http://codex.wordpress.org/Template_Tags/comments_number
My single.php file has this:
<a href="<?php comments_link(); ?>"><?php comments_number('No Responses Yet','One Response','% Responses'); ?></a>
Which is the same as the one HandySolo has, except instead of #comments, it has that php comments_link, which I don’t really understand, but I think it is basically the same thing, because that’s where that link points.
richarduk, I can’t find the relevent part of my comments.php so I just put the whole thing in the pastebin if someone wants to take a look at it.
Meanwhile, I’m going to check out that link and try to decipher it. π Thanks!
line 28
<h3> Write a comment ...
Change it to <h3 id="comments"> Write a comment ....
That should take you to the top of the comment form from any links
Okay! Thank you!
I ended up putting that on line 6 though, so it would take you to the top of the comments section instead of the comment form. Because when a reader clicks on “6 comments” I want it to take them to the beginning of the comments.
But I wonder if there’s a way to do this: When there are no comments yet, have it take them to the beginning of the comment form. Because this way, it just takes them to the top of the post if there aren’t any comments.
Hmmm… if I can’t do that, maybe I will do what you said and have it take them to the comment form.
Okay, I just put that code (<h3 id="comments"> on both lines 6 and 28 (“Comments” and “Write a Comment”) and it seems to be working. If I click on “No responses yet” (on a post that has 0 comments) it takes me to the top of the comment form, and if I click on one that has comments, it takes me to the top of the comments. I don’t know why that
works, but it does.
Is it incorrect and going mess up my site though?
Sorry, I replied aand then the support forum seemed to crash. Probably unrelated.
When you link to your post you’ll have either #respond or #comments added on by WordPress, depending on whether or not there are comments. Mouseover the link and look at the status bar.
I would delete one of your id=”comments” and replace it with id=”respond” and see what happens.
You shouldn’t have two identical ids on the same page – that would prevent your page validating.
Finally, your anchor doesn’t need to be id=”respond”, it could be a name=”respond” (sorry, code not rendering when try to edit it)
a name="respond">blah</a>
hmm, I tried changing the second one to respond, but it doesn’t work. I think I’d need to change something else somewhere too, but I don’t know what.
Okay, I’ve completely given up on that theme’s comment template and now I’m just using the Default WP theme’s comment.php. Finally, things work. You can even click directly to a particular comment, which is great.
Now my only problem is what I had there before: It has the “respond” id, but when there are no comments, it still just links to the beginning of the post, rather than the Comment form. I think I need to put something in my index.php template, but I’m not sure what. Right now, it just tells it to link to the comments, and if there are none, it doesn’t know what to do so it just goes to the top of the post.
Here’s the little varmint that creates all the #respond and #comment stuff – I’ve copied and pasted from my notes:
<?php comments_popup_link('Your wording for no comments', 'Your wording for one comment', 'Your wording for there were % comments', 'Your-CSS-style-name', 'Your wording for no comments allowed'); ?>
% gives the number of comments, Your-CSS-style-name is the CSS style that you want to use to style the comments link.
Links to posts that have no comments will have #respond added to them. This links to the anchor <h3 id="respond"> found within comments.php and takes the user diretly to the comment input form at the bottom of the post.
Links to posts with comments will have #comments added to them. This links to the anchor <h3 id="comments"> in comments.php – in other words, it takes the user directly to the first comment, so that they can read it.
You have been so helpful. It is working. Only, I’m still not sure what you mean by the CSS style name. Should it be the name of my css file? Like, style.css? Or the name of the thingie (don’t know what it’s called: class? element?) that defines the that particular thing in my css file.
That probably doesn’t make sense. Here’s what I had before:
<p class="postinfo"><a href="<?php comments_link(); ?>"> <?php comments_number('No comments','1 Comment','% Comments'); ?></a></p>
And now I have:
<p class="postinfo">
<?php comments_popup_link('Would you like to leave a comment?', 'One Comment', '% Comments', 'Your-CSS-style-name', 'Comments Disabled on this Post'); ?></p>
It seems to be working right like that, but I want to know what to put in place of “your css style name”. Is it <p class="postinfo"> or some variant?
Good question.
The answer is that your-csss-style-name is a class that’s added to your link.
<p class="postinfo"> <a href="http://www.mysite.com/?p=24#respond" class="your-csss-style-name" title="Comment on pears post">No Comments - be the first!</a> </p>
So you could change your-css-style-name to something like comment-link-style.
In your stylesheet style.css you have styles for links probablye something along the lines of:
a:hover {font-weight:bold}
a:link {font-weight:normal)
a:visited {font-weight:bold}
You now want to create a specific class of links (you don’t have to, you can have your comment links looking the same as all the other links, it’s just an option and if you do nothing your comment links will look just like the other links)
But IF you want your comment links to look different, do this:
a.comment-link-style:link {font-style:italic}
a.comment-link-style:visited (font-style:normal}
a.comment-link-style:hover {font-style:italic}
π
