Unwanted Noindex of Page 2

WordPress version: 3.4.2
WordPress SEO version: 1.2.8.7

I did this: Never asked the pluguin to “Noindex subpages of archives”
I have no checkmark there for noindex, neither do I have it anywhere else.

I expected the plugin to do this: No to add a noindex in the header of the page.

Instead it did this: For /page/2/ i get a:
<meta name="robots" content="noindex,follow"/>
On http://www.dive.in/page/2/ etc, I get a unwanted noindex. Author pages – the only other place on my blog that also have /page/2/ etc – has no problem with noindex.

http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/wordpress-seo/